Best Pitching Gloves for the Next Strikeout in 2021

Best Pitching Gloves

Baseball Eagle is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

If last summer wasn’t the ball season you hoped for, you probably want to burst onto the scene in 2021. From pockets to materials, every aspect of your baseball mitt matters, especially when you step on the mound. 

At A Glance: OUR TOP 5 PICKS FOR BASEBALL PITCHING GLOVES

We compiled a list of the best pitching gloves to help you make the most of your 2021 season. You can even read up on some tips to help you shop for your next glove!

The Best Pitching Gloves

IMAGE PRODUCT DETAILS
basballeagle-table__imageRawlings Heart of the Hide Glove
  • Made from high-quality materials
  • 2-piece solid webbing
  • Padded thumb sleeve for comfort
VIEW ON AMAZON →
basballeagle-table__image2021 Wilson A2K D3322
  • Stylish, sturdy pocket that conceals grip
  • Lightweight but durable
  • 11.75” glove is larger and more versatile
VIEW ON AMAZON →
basballeagle-table__imageEaston Prime Series PME1150
  • Made with soft Buffalo leather
  • Unique web design conceals grip
  • Attractive two-tone coloring
VIEW ON AMAZON →
basballeagle-table__imageWilson A2000 Clayton Kershaw Game Model
  • Clayton Kershaw's game glove design
  • High-quality materials
  • DriLex wrist lining
VIEW ON AMAZON →
basballeagle-table__imageMizuno Prospect PowerClose Youth
  • Tartan flex webbing helps disguise grip
  • PowerClose feature
  • Full-grain pigskin leather with Mzo lining
VIEW ON AMAZON →

Best Pitching Glove – Rawlings Heart of the Hide Glove (Our Top Pick)

Rawlings Heart of The Hide Pitcher's Glove

Classic, stylish, and versatile are the three words that come to mind for this pitching glove.

Should You Buy This?

YES:

Rawlings uses high-quality leather for this line of gloves, the top 5% of available steer hides, to be exact. Even the lacing, Tennessee Tanning rawhide leather, is top of the line, so you can expect this glove to last.

No matter what color combination you choose, these gloves look classy. You even have the option to choose a solid-colored glove, like black. The only other color on the glove is the red Rawlings logo and white stitching. This option could be helpful for those umpires who don’t like multi-colored gloves.

The Heart of the Hide gloves also features a padded thumb sleeve for extra comfort. Additionally, the 2-piece solid webbing is a pitcher’s dream for disguising grips, yet it’s versatile enough for use anywhere in the infield.

One final perk for the Rawlings Heart of the Hide gloves is that the manufacturer pre-oils them to decrease the amount of time you have to spend breaking it in. Rawlings estimates that the glove ships 30% broken-in leaving the player to handle the remaining 70% for a custom fit.

NO:

The one comment that kept coming up about this glove is that it feels smaller than described. It doesn’t seem to matter what size glove you purchase; it feels smaller during play than it is. Some people noted that it felt off between a half-inch and three-quarters of an inch.

The Good

  • Made from high-quality materials
  • 2-piece solid webbing
  • Pre-oiled for shorter player break-in time
  • Padded thumb sleeve for comfort

The Bad

  • Feels smaller than it is

The Verdict

This glove is a reasonable option for pitchers who love a classic look. It’s made from high-quality materials and includes extra comfort features, like a padded thumb sleeve.

The 2-piece solid webbing is perfect for the mound, but if you happen to play other positions, it’s versatile enough to make the shift. Since it comes 30% broken-in from the factory, you have a shorter break-in time and still create that custom fit.


Best Pocket – 2021 Wilson A2K D3322

2021 Wilson A2K D33SS 11.75" Pitcher's Baseball Glove

Having a good pocket matters, and Wilson’s A2K D33SS is a pitcher’s dream!

Should You Buy This?

YES:

To be clear, the 2021 gloves were released late, so there’s not a lot of feedback about this glove, especially regarding long-term use. However, we have plenty to discuss how it looks and feels fresh from the factory.

Start with the pocket featuring a closed Pro Lace Web that looks awesome while concealing your grip. The tan lacing is decorative against the black leather, and the combination can easily withstand the wear and tear of pitching.

Speaking of high-quality materials, Wilson uses SuperSkin and SnakeSkin Pro Stock Select Leather to create a lightweight but durable glove. It’s made to hold its shape without weighing down your hand.

This glove is larger at 11.75” for a versatile fielding glove, and it undergoes three times more shaping during production to reduce your break-in time. It also features a double palm construction for extra padding and stability.

NO:

Make no mistake, this glove packs a punch and looks the part. However, it may be too much glove for some pitchers. It’s lightweight, but it could take some getting used to, especially if you’re used to a heavier glove.

The Good

  • Stylish, sturdy pocket that conceals grip
  • Lightweight but durable 
  • 11.75” glove is larger and more versatile
  • Double palm construction provides padding and stability

The Bad

  • MIght be too much glove for some pitchers

The Verdict

The 2021 Wilson A2K D3322 pitcher’s glove looks sharp and has a lot of awesome features, but since it’s so new, there’s not a lot of feedback yet. In past years, A2K gloves received rave reviews for craftsmanship, style, and durability.

We expect this glove to perform well in the long-term, thanks to high-quality materials and Wilson’s history of producing amazing gloves. If you’re in the market for a new pitcher’s glove, it would be tough to pass this one over.


Most Affordable Pitching Glove – Easton Prime Series PME1150

Easton Prime Series Infield Glove

Easton’s Prime Series glove is a good balance of reasonable pricing and quality.

Should You Buy This?

YES:

When you need an affordable glove that can handle the mound, Easton’s Prime Series has your back. It sports an attractive two-tone design with Easton’s logo in a complementary color. The glove is smooth and supple thanks to the soft Buffalo leather that feels great and reduces your break-in time.

Easton chose a combo-design for the pocket to make this 11.5” glove durable but not too heavy or awkward. This glove is well-crafted like other Easton brand items, and it features the proprietary VRS palm pad for added comfort and protection.

Though the webbing isn’t completely solid, it does a decent job of concealing your grip. It’s comfortable on your hand and flexible enough to feel confident fielding.

NO:

There’s not much to complain about with this glove if you take it at face value. This glove isn’t a premium piece of equipment like some of the others on this list, and you can tell by the lack of special features. 

Other than the palm, there’s no extra padding, and you don’t have a range of color options. This glove features quality materials, but they aren’t high-quality.

The Good

  • Made with soft Buffalo leather for easy break-in
  • Unique web design conceals grip and keeps the ball secure
  • Features a VRS palm pad for comfort and shock resistance
  • Attractive two-tone coloring

The Bad

  • Basic glove with no bells and whistles

The Verdict

If you want a premium glove, this isn’t it. However, not everybody can swing the cost of a premium baseball glove, but that doesn’t mean you can’t score a quality pitcher’s mitt for a fair price. Easton’s Prime Series proves that you can find a durable, affordable glove with plenty of function to please any pitcher on a budget.


Best for Experienced Pitchers – Wilson A2000 Clayton Kershaw Game Model

Wilson A2000 Baseball Pitcher's Glove

Look and feel like a professional with this glove modeled after Clayton Kershaw’s

Should You Buy This?

YES:

The stylish design is almost impossible to overlook, especially since it mimics the one Clayton Kershaw uses. It’s chic without being flashy or losing functionality. The solid color scheme sets off the branding but won’t distract picky umpires.  

Once you get beyond the first impressions, it’s easy to see how much thought went into creating this glove. The two-piece web is flexible enough to catch a ball but solid enough to conceal your grip from the competition. Additionally, the pocket features Dual Welting to improve durability.

Wilson also incorporated a DriLex wrist lining to pull sweat away from your hand and keep you cooler. Naturally, the manufacturer used high-quality leather to ensure this glove can stand the test of time.

NO:

This glove is a fan favorite, so don’t expect to find a lot of complaints. However, if you look closely at the reviews, it’s clear that most users are experienced players. Even the youngest kids to use it have several years of experience on the mound before jumping into this one, so it’s really not a starter glove.

We would not recommend this glove for inexperienced players, especially pitchers, given the size and structure. It was made with input from professional players with high-level play in mind.

The Good

  • Stylish design looks like Clayton Kershaw’s game glove
  • High-quality materials
  • DriLex wrist lining keeps your hand cooler
  • Two-piece web conceals grip

The Bad

  • Not for the inexperienced pitcher or player

The Verdict

When it comes to the best pitching gloves, the Wilson A2000 is an impressive option. However, it’s not the best choice for inexperienced pitchers (or players) because it was made to suit high-level play.

This pitching glove is gorgeous and comfortable to work with. It breaks in fast and can serve an experienced pitcher well on the mound, thanks to the two-piece webbing.


Best Youth Pitching Glove – Mizuno Prospect PowerClose Youth

Mizuno Prospect PowerClose Pitcher Glove

This glove is a young pitcher’s dream and a solid foundation for future success.

Should You Buy This?

YES:

Young pitchers need a good glove that builds confidence and gives them a little extra support. Mizuno’s Prospect PowerClose baseball glove achieves these goals and more.

Let’s start with the tartan flex webbing that makes it easier for young pitchers to hide their grip. Since they are just starting out, it can take a bit longer to find the proper grip for each pitch, but it’s not a problem with this glove.

Perhaps one of the best features of this glove is the PowerClose technology, which makes catching the ball much easier. Anybody who has ever worked with young pitchers can tell you how important it is to catch the ball when it’s thrown back from the catcher.

Additionally, Mizuno used an MZO lining that draws sweat away from the skin and built in a Parashock pad to deaden the impact of a ball hitting the palm. This glove also features an AirMesh back for more flexibility and breathability.

NO:

This glove may be a bit challenging to break in, which can be frustrating for a young player. Parents may have to give it some serious work before letting a young pitcher use it.

The Good

  • Tartan flex webbing helps disguise grip
  • PowerClose feature helps younger pitchers catch the ball
  • Full-grain pigskin leather glove with Mzo lining
  • Features Parashock palm pad for extra cushion

The Bad

  • Stiff and difficult to break-in

The Verdict

Mizuno’s Prospect looks and feels like an adult glove, but it has features made for a young player. Though it may need more work to break it in than a synthetic glove, it’s worth the effort.

This glove offers impressive comfort and protection to help a novice pitcher build confidence on the mound. Mizuno makes quality gloves, and this one is no exception.


More About Pitching Gloves

Though pitching requires a lot of practice, you also need a durable, flexible, and comfortable glove. There are multiple factors to consider when choosing the best pitching glove to meet your needs, like pocket coverage. Some issues come down to personal preference, while others have general rules of thumb.

Let’s dig a little deeper into the most important factors. Remember, no glove is going to make you a superstar — you need to practice, even on your own with a pitching net!

How Important is the Pocket?

The pocket is one of the most important aspects of choosing a pitching glove. An open pocket could give your competition a glimpse of your grip and tell them what you’re about to throw. Do you really want the batter to know you’re about to offer up a fastball?

While some pitchers find ways to work with any pocket arrangement, most prefer extra coverage, like a two-piece webbing. It helps to have as much coverage as possible, especially since you can also use the glove to cover your mouth during meetings on the mound.

What is the Difference Between Synthetic and Leather Gloves?

Unless you play tee-ball, you probably won’t have a need for a synthetic glove. Synthetic materials don’t have much flexibility, and you can’t break them in. They tend to be stiff and difficult to catch with. Additionally, the synthetic gloves feel slick, which means balls can roll right out.

Leather is the ultimate choice for a pitcher’s glove because it’s easy to handle once you break it in. There are different types of leather, and technological advancements led to new lightweight options. Overall, leather is softer and more pliable for catching the ball.

The downside of leather is that it’s far more expensive than a synthetic. You pay for the quality, durability, and longer life-span of a leather glove.

Is There a Difference Between Pitcher’s Gloves and Other Types?

Though some manufacturers market certain styles as “pitcher’s gloves,” they are usually infield gloves. Typically, there are four different classes of baseball (or softball) gloves.

  • First Baseman’s Gloves can be larger than other positions, but not exceeding thirteen inches from top to bottom or eight inches wide.
  • Catchers Mitts have unique shapes and extra padding to protect them from high-speed pitches.
  • Infield Gloves tend to be shorter, usually 11.25” up to 11.75” to make it quick and easy to get the ball out of the pocket.
  • Outfield Gloves share the features of infield gloves but tend to be longer to give fielders more reach.

It’s important to note that some organizations, including Major League Baseball (MLB), have special rules about pitcher’s gloves. Most of the regulations apply to color combinations and preclude certain materials and foreign substances.

What is the Best Brand for Pitching Gloves?

Perhaps the most challenging question to answer about any sporting gear is the best brand to choose. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference, and usually, once somebody decides on a brand, they stick with them for the duration of their career.

In terms of baseball gloves, there are some major brands competing for the top spot. We would say that the top brands are Rawlings, Wilson, Mizuno, and Easton. Each brand offers unique concepts and proprietary features, but you can feel confident purchasing from any of them.

What’s the Best Way to Care for a Pitching Glove?

There’s a good chance that your glove comes with suggested care instructions that you should follow. Just in case you didn’t get some, or you misplaced them, we’ve got some reliable tips to keep your glove game-ready.

  • Maintain your glove regularly to extend its life.
  • Clean it between uses, especially if you play in the mud. Use a clean rag.
  • Keep your glove in a cool, dry place. Avoid high-heat and the elements at all costs because your glove gets enough exposure during the season!
  • Condition your glove as needed with a leather-safe product to keep it pliable and prevent drying.
  • Monitor your glove for signs of worn laces and open seams. Most of these issues, like tightening laces, can be handled on your own. For major repairs, see a professional.

Don’t forget to thoroughly clean your glove at the end of a season. If you play year-round, try to work in these cleanings once or twice per year.

  • Use a light, gentle brush to wipe away dirt and debris.
  • Apply a bit of leather cleaner to a clean, damp cloth or sponge and gently wipe down your entire glove.
  • Wipe away the cleaner with a fresh, damp cloth and allow your glove to air dry.
  • Apply a leather-safe conditioner using a clean cloth. 

How Do I Know My Pitching Glove Needs Conditioning?

It depends on where you live. You don’t want the leather to dry out, so if you live in a drier climate, you may need to condition it more frequently than somebody who lives in a humid area.

How Do I Know When It’s Time to Replace My Pitching Glove?

How safe do you feel catching a line drive with your glove? If you shy away from liners because you don’t think the webbing can hold or the padding is too thin, then it’s probably time for an upgrade.